Challenging Dogma - Spring 2011

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Let's Move! Over-emphasizes Individual Choice and Under-utilizes Modern Psychological Theories to Address Childhood Obesity - Kathryn Rodgers

Michelle Obama's “Let's Move!” campaign reaches out to children, parents, teachers, chefs, and government officials to combat the childhood obesity epidemic in America. However, its approach to reach these individuals is largely fact-based, and it fails to address fundamental social constructs that contribute to the problem. At present, The First Lady's campaign's biggest achievement is its contribution to awareness of the issue. However, more awareness is not needed. Constant media coverage floods Americans with information about the childhood obesity epidemic, such as the television show “Honey We're Killing the Kids,” and daily newspaper headlines that read: “Child Obesity Risks Death at Early Age, Study Finds (1).” Around 30% of all American children between two and nineteen years of age are classified as obese or overweight, and 17% of all American children in this age group are classified as obese (2). It is also well known that obesity is a significant risk factor for developing other diseases, such as type 2 diabetes, heart disease, hypertension, stroke, liver disease, and certain types of cancers, to name some (3). Awareness campaigns have already been effective; 80% of all Americans recognize that childhood obesity and its health consequences are a concerning problem in this country (4). However, such campaigns are not sufficient to combat the obesity epidemic. The public health field needs to move away from “filling education gaps” and instead use modern solutions for modern problems. The traditional behavioral models that shape public health interventions need to be updated.

The nation's banner approach to address the growing obesity problem is Michelle Obama's “Let's Move!” campaign, which has the ambitious goal of “solving the challenge of childhood obesity within a generation (5).” This paper will critique three of the social-behavioral approaches that govern the presentation of information on the “Let's Move!” website and suggest alternative methods to make this public health intervention successful.

“Let's Move!” is Modeled on the Health Belief Model

“Let's Move!” ignores the fundamental social causes of childhood obesity by ascribing to the Health Belief Model. The Health Belief Model was developed in the 1950s by a group of U.S. Public Health Service social psychologists, and it is one of the oldest and most popular individual behavioral theories used in public health (6). The model appeals to individuals to change their behavior based upon a cost-benefit analysis. The focus is on individuals' motivational attitudes toward a health outcome by recognizing their personal susceptibility and the potential severity of experiencing the health outcome. The individual then weighs the barriers and costs of achieving the health outcome against the benefits of avoiding the health outcome. The goal is for individuals to permanently change their behavior to prevent the health outcome. The problems with this approach are that it relies solely on the individual to change, despite their circumstances, and it assumes that people make rational cost-benefit decisions about their health. The following figure illustrates the early formation of the Health Belief Model (6):



The “Let's Move!” homepage showcases five tabs that are a near perfect fit to the original Health Belief Model diagram (7):



The health outcome is childhood obesity in this case, and “Learn the Facts” provides information about who is at risk and the detrimental health outcomes for those who are obese. “Eat Healthy” and “Get Active” display the benefits of living a healthier life, and the barriers, (daily exercise and consistently preparing healthy meals) to avoid obesity. The costs to the individual are presented on the “Take Action” page by demonstrating the necessary steps to successfully prevent obesity. The hope is to have readers make their way through each page in order, ending on the “Join Us” page, and then commit to behavioral changes.

The most basic flaw of the Health Belief Model is that it places the responsibility for change with the individual. A psychological phenomenon called the Fundamental Attribution Error states that people are likely to blame another person's faults for weaknesses in their personality, instead of their environment (8). The “Learn the Facts” page is fault to the Fundamental Attribution Error by stating that personal choices, such as riding the bus to school as opposed to walking; spending time playing video games; and eating too many snacks are the reasons for the tripled rate in childhood obesity in the past 30 years (5). From a sociological perspective, lifestyle is considered a “socially determined pattern of consumption or marker of status, which suggests that one's lifestyle is not within one's personal control (6). However, “Let’s Move!” does not take into account societal circumstances that we cannot control, such as agricultural subsidies, companies' investments, or socioeconomic factors that influence people's access to nutritious food. The “Learn the Facts” information about the cause of obesity does not acknowledge that for some children, walking to school is not a possibility. It may not be feasible for a child to walk along a highway or through a dangerous neighborhood to get to school. Additionally, “Let's Move!” does not address households in which parent(s) are working multiple jobs and cannot devote sufficient time to work on healthy habits with their children. The “Let's Move!” campaign attempts to educate its target audiences by listing the proximate causes of obesity and instructing them to make changes to isolated behaviors. The assumption that individuals have total control over their choices is the cardinal defect of the Health Belief Model.

Leaving the Fundamental Attribution Error out of the equation, The Health Belief Model is still flawed. Although this model can be useful for one-time behaviors, such as getting vaccinated, it is not an appropriate model to use for long-lasting changes. The core breakdown of this model's approach to childhood obesity is that it assumes an individual reading the website will make permanent changes in their lifestyle. People have the best of intentions, and even if they click “Join Us” to sign the pledge, there is no guarantee that their motivation will last through their lifetime, or even throughout the next day. Even if an individual had ideal access to nutritious food and time to exercise, it is unrealistic to expect that children or their parents will rationally analyze every food and exercise choice with equal scrutiny at each time they are hungry or feeling too tired to exercise. Psychologist George Loewenstein discovered that state-dependent mindsets differ based on the situation (9). He describes an individual’s decision making states as either “cold,” meaning rational or “hot,” meaning irrational (9). For instance, in a rational or “cold” state of mind, a person may vow to make healthful diet changes. However, when that same person is in a “hot” state, say they are incredibly hungry and tired after a busy day, they may reach for a bag of chips, despite their certain knowledge that making a salad would be healthier. Human nature does not provide us with the ability to make rational decisions on a consistent basis. The Health Belief Model ignores the impact of societal circumstances that influence an individual's ability to control their own lifestyle, and it wrongly assumes that humans are always capable of making rational decisions.

“Let's Move! Induces Psychological Reactance

The instructive manner in which the campaign is presented does not appropriately appeal to the target audience. Psychological Reactants Theory explains why this intervention is not persuasive enough, and may even turn people away. The first image on the homepage of the “Let's Move!” website is a still-frame of The First Lady speaking about the one year anniversary of the campaign. She is sitting very still in a wooden chair inside the White House, wearing a closed-mouth smile and a white, high-neck blouse. Her speech is stoic and congratulatory toward the campaign's own efforts, including government officials and the passage of congressional acts. She emphasizes Americans’ individual responsibility to raise healthy children and encourages more involvement. Although she is an attractive spokesperson, there is little else that makes her compelling to her audience. Psychological studies by Dr. Paul Silva on message delivery have shown that messages are better received when the communicator of the message displays similar characteristics to the recipient (10). Jack Brehm developed Psychological Reactance Theory, which states that “interpersonal similarity can reduce reactance by increasing compliance and by reducing resistance (10).” Obesity disproportionally affects children of lower socioeconomic status. One in three low-income children aged 2-4 are obese or overweight, compared to one in three children aged two to nineteen being obese or overweight in the general population (11). By seating herself inside the White House, she is making herself about as unfamiliar as possible to the affected children and their parents. She also glaringly fails to acknowledge her own challenges and efforts to ensure healthful lifestyles for her own two children. Her lack of relatable characteristics and uncharismatic demeanor makes it difficult to pay attention, much less relate to The First Lady.

Psychological Reactance Theory also illustrates that an adverse reaction can be elicited when people's freedom to make autonomous decisions is threatened (10). The authoritarian message of decisions children and their parents should make, is the basis of the Republican Party's criticisms of the “Let's Move!” campaign. Republican spokespeople are worried that the government is attempting to tell Americans how to live their lives and raise their children (12). The predictable reaction to the threat of freedom is anger. Despite the near unanimous agreement that the nation's childhood obesity epidemic needs to be addressed, the campaign has lost people's interest by overtly telling people what they should and should not do.

“Let's Move!” Creates Negative Racial Labels

The way in which “Let's Move!” stratifies obesity statistics and risk factors by race and ethnicity and creates negative labels. The dangers of creating labels for children are well known; labeling can “preserve a social hierarchy by keeping minority group children from opportunities and delay needed social reform (13).” Racial labels have been shown to influence health outcomes, which may be caused by institutional or internalized racism (14). The very first paragraph of information on the “Learn the Facts” page of the campaign's website highlights the higher rates of childhood obesity in minority groups. Nearly 40% of children are overweight or obese in African American or Hispanic communities (6). Showcasing stratified statistics based on race only creates negative labels for these children to identify themselves and others. The danger of labels is twofold. It forms stereotypes and it may also prime children to internalized racism. Internalized racism is defined as “acceptance by members of the stigmatized races of negative messages about their own abilities and intrinsic worth (14).” If Hispanic children are told that they are more likely to be obese than their non-minority counterparts, they may internalize this negative information as a problem with their race or ethnicity. Aside from racism, these statistics may create expectations that are fulfilled, thus confirming the statistics' own accuracy, a psychological phenomena called a self-fulfilling prophecy (15). The children who are told they are more likely to become obese are prone to meet those expectations. The African American children who hear that they are at risk of being overweight may fulfill that expected role and become overweight as a result. Overweight children already face bullying at school; one study found that obese children in the 6th grade were 60% more likely to be bullied than other non-obese children (16).

The focus on race's effect on obesity, combined with the entire campaign's presentation under the Health Belief Model, implies that there must inherently be something about African Americans and Hispanics that either makes them unable to “learn the facts” about obesity or control their diet and exercise. The insinuation that people are simply uneducated about what it means to be healthy is ignorant on the campaign's part. The racial statistics about obesity ignore all of the other factors other than race, such as socioeconomic status, access to food, and even where neighbors grocery shop, all of which may influence a person's access to healthy food and daily exercise (17). A peripheral link on the campaign’s website recognizes that the psychological stress of social stigmas and its effect on self-esteem is an additional impact on children with obesity. It should take additional steps to avoid providing more ways for social stigmas to take hold.

Proposed Interventions to Bolster “Let's Move!” Effectiveness

The three critiques described above can be rectified by using alternative social-behavioral approaches and changing the framework of campaign's current behavior models. The sources of America’s food are businesses and corporations. Replacing the individual-based Health Belief Model to an approach that focuses on food companies and retailers would appropriately eliminate the reliance on individual choice to solve childhood obesity. Walmart is a great example of a company that has recently partnered with the First Lady to change their retail environment in order to promote healthier choices for their shoppers. However, this change is not described on the “Let's Move!” website. A new agenda directed at food manufacturers and sellers, such as Walmart, would be a more tangible plan that can actually change people's access to healthy foods. “Let's Move!” would garner more interest in the campaign by working within the framework of psychological reactance. There are multiple examples of very compelling media that would better reach the campaign's target audience, such as Beyonce's new music video that partners with “Let's Move!” called “Move Your Body.” Replacing the boring images and videos of Michelle Obama on the website with influential media would be a great place to start. Eliminating the racial labels of obesity, and instead showing that all efforts have equal success across race would reduce stereotypes and the negative consequences of them. These proposed changes could completely replace the five tabs on the website's homepage. The new homepage would have three imaged tabs that read: “Move your Body with Beyonce,” “Find Your Favorite Healthy Foods at These Stores,” and “See Who Else is Moving.” An example prototype is shown below:


“Let's Move!” needs to bring corporate behavior, as opposed to individual behavior, to the forefront of the campaign's presentation. Given that individuals' choices are largely dictated by their environment, the most obvious way to bring about individual change is by modifying the environment. Since the underlying social and economic structures are entrenched in society, it is more feasible to change corporate practices to promote health behaviors than to change the fabric of society (18). In a similar manner to how the anti-smoking public health campaigns targeted cigarette manufacturers as the responsible party to make a change, the corporate contributions to the childhood obesity epidemic should be addressed. Although this may initially seem like a politically contentious and near impossible task for the government to accomplish, Walmart has shown that it can be done within a free market system.

Michelle Obama has already taken a step in the right direction by working with the superstore chain Walmart. Walmart stores now have fully stocked grocery stores in addition to the general goods that “mart” stores typically sell. The superstore is the nation's largest grocery chain, serving about 140 million customers a week (19). The company has partnered with “Let’s Move!” by adopting a five year plan to reduce the amount of fats, salt, and refined sugars in the food they sell (20). Additionally, Walmart will develop “health seals” to label their food. Part of Walmart's plan to increase healthy food access is to open more stores with access to affordable healthy food in rural areas as well as small stores in cities (20). This is great example of how other grocers can advertise their stores to the masses, while boosting their image of standing next to The First Lady's efforts to create a healthier nation of children. Instead of telling her audience to “Eat Healthy,” Mrs. Obama can instead point to businesses that are showing commitment to the campaign's goals and even help people to get their local grocer to offer healthier food choices through signing letters to voice their consumer desires.

Since “Let's Move!” is already partnered with Walmart, it would be ideal if the two organizations could collaborate to produce a shopping list for the week, complete with healthy, simple recipes for the whole family. If Walmart could have a sanctioned section of the store with the week's grocery-list items rotating through each week, it would attract people's attention inside the store. It would be even more effective if Walmart could have special discounts on some of those items for the week. “The target groups identified by Wal-Mart’s market researchers are Hispanics, African Americans, “empty-nesters/boomers,” affluent, suburban and rural shoppers, according to [company president] Castro-Wright (21).” Walmart's customer base of Americans of all racial and socioeconomic backgrounds makes it an ideal venue to influence a huge number of people.

“Let's Move!” Should Focus on Efforts to Reduce Psychological Reactance

Beyonce's new flash workout video “Move Your Body” should be the flagship song of the “Let's Move!” campaign. There were over two million views of the YouTube video within the first six days of its posting. Beyonce is an incredibly popular celebrity, and putting her dance on the homepage of the “Let's Move!” website would attract potentially millions of viewers. Given that most people are already very familiar with Beyonce and associate her with fun and entertainment, she does not elicit psychological reactance by communicating the message to exercise, or “move your body.” The video itself does not tell viewers what to do, instead it invites them to join in and dance with a catchy hip-hop beat and Beyonce's famous dance moves. Unsurprisingly, the video for the choreographed routine already has almost three hundred thousand YouTube views. However, Beyonce is nowhere to be found on the “Let's Move!” Youtube channel. The dismal viewership on the “Let's Move” channel reveals an average of about four thousand views per video. The most viewed video is a cartoon of utensils singing about eating breakfast.

Beyonce's video starts with a quick beat set by a boy tapping his pencils in a school cafeteria while other students in line for school lunch are seen eating apples, bananas, carrots, a fruit cup, and a small serving of spaghetti. A young overweight boy grabs the cafeteria’s attention as the song starts by moving his arms and stretching to get ready to dance. Other students join in clapping their hands, and Beyonce bursts out of the cafeteria kitchen in short shorts and high heels starting to lead the dance. This is a great example of how to reach an audience and avoid psychological reactance. Beyonce is dancing with the students, and her lyrics say things like, “This is how we do/Jump a couple to the right/To the left, let's move” and “Can you dougie with me?/Throw your own lil swag on this swizzy beat.” Although Beyonce has the same fundamental message as Michelle Obama, which is to motivate children to exercise, Beyonce's execution is far more effective. Already, elementary and middle schools have started to upload their own videos of children dancing to her song in the classroom and in physical education classes (22). The children look like they are having fun, and viewers’ comments on the YouTube video of Welch Middle School say things like, “Man, I wish our P.E. lessons were like this...” and “GREAT JOB YOU ALL!!!....Man I wish we had Beyonce when I was in P.E....maybe then I would've participated more...haha.” This is the exact reaction that the campaign needs; children want to be a part of this dance workout.

Highlight the Equality of Success

Instead of using statistics to educate and motivate its audience, “Let's Move!” should develop a social network to connect and feature a variety of children who are enjoying dancing, being active, and sharing their favorite healthy snacks. Showing the personal success stories of Hispanic and African American children working to becoming healthier would be a more effective motivational tool than simply showing numbers of their obesity risks. The link on the website with this content would be under “See Who Else is Moving!” Videos of children of every race and ethnicity should be broadcasted in order to break down the labels and stereotypes that exist about race and rate of obesity.

Social networking websites are widely used in America. Marketing a “Let's Move!” social network to appeal to its target audience would be a supportive meeting ground for people to talk about their questions, successes, and challenges. A social networking site would also be an appropriate platform for children and parents (although not necessarily together) to share recipes and preparing their favorite healthy foods. Although there is an entire television network to cooking food, the majority of celebrity chefs are Caucasian, and they perform in a staged, prep kitchen. “Let's Move!” could post cooking demonstrations in a believable format and also allow people to post their own cooking videos. Cooking demonstrations would be useful since many Americans do not know how to cook a variety of healthy meals. Some delicious examples could be as simple as “ants on a log” for a snack, spiced and mashed sweet potatoes, an egg frittata, pan fried vegetable patties, eggplant parmesan, guacamole, stir fry, creamed corn, or pasta with a vegetable sauce. There are so many easy, delicious dishes that could be advertised on the “Let's Move!” website. Healthy eating shouldn't be overshadowed by common food plugs for nutrition, such as blasé lettuce, apples, or carrots. The important thing to show is that there is no racial difference to becoming healthier, and everyone can be a part of the “Let's Move!” movement to dance (or another fun activity) and eat delicious food.

Conclusion

The entire nation's childhood obesity epidemic cannot be placed on the shoulders of individuals’ decisions to change their lifestyle. Although it is ultimately individuals who consume food and are active or inactive, the societal structure in which we exists largely determines the choices we will make. Any change that can be made to the environment that will open opportunities for healthy behavior should be explored. Walmart creating a more healthy retail environment is a great example of the positive impact a company can have. “Let's Move!” would benefit everyone by moving toward an approach that appeals to businesses to promote a healthy lifestyle.

Psychological theories can contribute valuable methods to better reach the American audience. Recognizing that humans don't always make rational decisions is crucial to developing an approach that is dependent upon choice. Currently, “Let's Move!” assumes that people who read the campaign materials will rationally start to change their behaviors. Again, creating more opportunities for healthy changes by altering the environment is a great way to create an approach that takes into account human psychology. Additionally, connecting with viewers is key, both through positive familiarity, such as Beyonce, and in ways that don't elicit reactance by threatening anyone's freedom.

Treating everyone with equal importance is an important way to gain people's trust. “Let's Move!” needs to avoid racial statistics, and instead focus on people of all races who are currently finding ways to stay active and eat delicious food. The campaign should highlight that the fun and excitement, as well as health benefits, of dancing and cooking can be appreciated by everybody across all demographics.

REFERENCES

1. Rabin, R. (February 10, 2010). Child Obesity Risks Death at Early Age, Study Finds. The New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/11/health/11fat.html

2. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Data and Statistics: Obesity Rates Among all Children in the United States. Atlanta, GA. http://www.cdc.gov/obesity/childhood/data.html

3. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Overweight and Obesity: Health Consequence. Atlanta, GA. http://www.cdc.gov/obesity/causes/health.html

4. Trust for America's Health. F as in Fat: How Obesity Threatens America's Future 2010. Washington, DC. http://healthyamericans.org/reports/obesity2010/

5. Let's Move! Learn the Facts. Washington, DC. http://www.letsmove.gov/learn-facts/epidemic-childhood-obesity

6. Social and Behavioral Sciences for Public Health Spring 2011, Boston University School of Public Health: Individual health behavior theories (chapter 4). In: Edberg M. Essentials of Health Behavior: Social and Behavioral Theory in Public Health. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett Publishers, 2007, pp. 35-49.

7. Let's Move! Washington, DC. http://www.letsmove.gov

8. Tetlock, E. Accountability: A social check on the fundamental attribution error. Social Psychology Quarterly 1985; 3:227-236. http://www.jstor.org/pss/3033683

9. Social and Behavioral Sciences for Public Health Spring 2011, Boston University School of Public Health: Ogden, J. Some problems with social cognition models: a pragmatic and conceptual analysis. Health Psychology 2003; 22:424-428.

10. Social and Behavioral Sciences for Public Health Spring 2011, Boston University School of Public Health: Siliva PJ. Deflecting reactance: The role of similarity in increasing compliance and reducing resistance. Basic and Applied Social Psychology 2005; 27:277-284.

11. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Data and Statistics: Obesity Rates Among Low-Income Preschool Children. Atlanta, GA. http://www.cdc.gov/obesity/childhood/data.html

12. Oliphant, J. Conservatives heap criticism on Michelle Obama's campaign against childhood obesity. February 27, 2011. Tribune Washington Bureau http://www.cleveland.com/nation/index.ssf/2011/02/conservatives_heap_criticism_o.html

13. Gallagher, J. The Sacred and Profane Uses of Labeling. Mental Retardation, Vol 14(6), Dec 1976, 3-7. http://psycnet.apa.org/psycinfo/1977-21290-001

14. Social and Behavioral Sciences for Public Health Spring 2011, Boston University School of Public Health: Jones CP. Levels of racism: A theoretic framework and a gardener's tale. American Journal of Public Health 2009; 90:1212-1215.

15. Watzlawick, P. Self-Fulfilling Prophecies. In: O'Brien, J. The Production of Reality: Essays and Readings on Social Interaction. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press, 2011. http://books.google.com/

16. Lumeng, J., et al. Weight Status as a Predictor of Being Bullied in Third through Sixth Grades. Pediatrics, Vol 125 (6), June 2010. http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/abstract/peds.2009-0774v1?maxtoshow=&hits=10&RESULTFORMAT=&fulltext=lumeng&searchid=1&FIRSTINDEX=0&sortspec=relevance&resourcetype=HWCIT

17. Inagami, S., et al. You Are Where You Shop. American Journal of Preventive Medicine. Volume 1 (31), July 2006, 10-17. http://health.dailynewscentral.com/content/view/0002276/89/

18. Social and Behavioral Sciences for Public Health Spring 2011, Boston University School of Public Health: Freudenberg, N. Galea S. The impact of corporate practices on health: implications for health policy. Journal of Public Health Policy 2008; 29:86-104.

19. Steinman, E. Can Walmart Make 140 Million Americans Healthier? January 21, 2011. Care2: Healthy and Green Living. Redwood City, CA. http://www.care2.com/greenliving/capitalism-and-nutrition-align-walmart-does-what-they-can-to-make-140-million-americans-healthier.html

20. Nyhold, C. Walmart Joins First Lady Michelle Obama's Let's Move Campaign. Social Justice Examiner. Denver, CO. http://www.examiner.com/social-justice-in-national/walmart-joins-first-lady-michelle-obama-s-let-s-move-campaign

21. Walmart to Drop One Size Fits All Approach. CNBC. http://www.cnbc.com/id/14714027/for/cnbc

22. Beyonce's Let's Move Flash Video Plea from Welch Middle School. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcWZlJP3BE0&feature=related

Labels: , , , ,

Sunday, May 8, 2011

Why Public Health Campaigns Are Failing At Preventing Teen Pregnancy

Nearly half of adolescents (46%) between the ages of 15-19yrs in the United States report being sexually active at least once [1]. This rate of sexuality is fairly consistent in many different countries; however, the United States has the highest rate of teen pregnancy of all developed countries [2]. This in part can be attributed to the fact that it takes on average 13 months before a female adolescent discusses birth control options with a clinician after their sexual debut and an adolescent having unprotected sex for 1 year has a 90% chance of getting pregnant [3, 4].

Not surprisingly, eighty-five percent of the 750,000 teenage pregnancies per year in the United States are unintended [1]. Approximately half of teenage pregnancies end in the birth of a child; the remaining proportion end in either abortion (30%) or miscarriage (20%).

Teen pregnancy and subsequent parenthood has consequences for both the mother and child [3-5]. Teen mothers are less likely to complete high school and more likely to be a victim of intimate-partner violence, live in poverty and be dependent on public assistance programs. The children of these mothers also have more chance of having cognitive disorders and being neglected or abused. Daughters have higher rates of subsequent teenage pregnancies and sons have increased rates of incarceration. Thus, there are long-lasting effects of teenage pregnancy and birth.

Because of the lack of comprehensive sex education in a vast majority of schools in the United States [6] and less than 5% of high schools distributing condoms [7], public service campaigns are often the only “safe sex” messages that are heard amongst a highly-sexualized society [8]. The National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy is an organization based in Massachusetts that provides information and various press around safe-sex and teenage pregnancy.

They have a series of Public Service Announcements (PSA) that were created “by young people, for young people” and are located on a website entitled “Sex Has Consequences.” The PSAs in general are not effective for a variety of reasons and one in particular features a male adolescent going through the routine of getting ready in the morning—including turning off an alarm clock, taking a shower, brushing his teeth, getting dressed and making breakfast. However, each of these tasks is complicated by the fact that his right hand has been replaced with a baby doll. The end of this 30-second commercial has a statement appear on the screen that asks the question “Why complicate your life?” The commercial then ends with “Sex Has Consequences” on the screen and a website address for further information [9]. The video is available at: http://www.wvdhhr.org/appi/psa/pages/videos/babyhand_30.html

There are three main reasons that this approach to preventing health issue unplanned teenage pregnancies is not effective.

Utilization of the Health Belief Model

The Health Belief Model is one of the original models utilized within public health [10]. In the arena of teenage pregnancy prevention, there are flaws to using this model which is based on the notion that adolescents will weigh the benefits and costs to avoiding pregnancy and adjust their behavior accordingly.

The health belief model assumes that adolescents will correctly perceive their susceptibility to pregnancy when they are sexually active. There has been evidence that this does not occur in young adults and you can assume that adolescent’s sense of invincibility only would exaggerate these results. A report published by the National Campaign to End Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy (the same organization that published this PSA) found that although a vast majority of young adults feel that pregnancy should be planned and avoiding pregnancy is very important to them now, almost 50% of those surveyed do not use contraception at all or consistently use contraception [11]. Additionally, one in five people surveyed admitted that it is extremely or very likely they will have unprotected sex in the next 3 months [11]. Therefore, despite the statistic that having unprotected sex for 1 year results in a 90% chance of pregnancy, a majority of sexual active adults do not utilize effective contraceptive methods. This disconnect between risk evaluation and behavior shakes the foundation of the health belief model itself.

Another component of the health belief model is that adolescents will understand the severity and consequences of teenage pregnancy and thus avoid it by practicing safe-sex. This is difficult to interpret in this commercial because of the lack of reality around the images used. Becoming pregnant or fathering a child does not lead to your hand becoming a baby doll and unusable. The message of this particular commercial centers around the idea of a baby being a complication to your life. However, the “complication” depicted in this commercial is having one less hand to use because the dexterity of the actors hand is lost when it is replaced by a baby doll. This results in a message that is unclear to understand for the viewer and somewhat confusing when trying to connect consequences with sexual behavior.

A final component of the health belief model is the assumption that intention leads to behavior. This tenant is complicated when it comes to sexual activity because few teenagers intend to get pregnant or contract a sexually transmitted infection. Instead, adolescents’ (or anyone for that matter) ability to control their behavior in the heat of the moment is limited. The immediate outcome and satisfaction from having sex is not linked to the behavior of safe sex in this commercial. This PSA also does not give any visual or literal idea to the viewer on how to control one’s behavior and incorporate safe sex into sexually activity. Instead, it just warns the viewer to not complicate their life with a baby.

Not Utilizing Modeling

This commercial and many commercials that focus around safe sex and avoiding pregnancy for adolescents do not utilize modeling as a component of the message. Instead, a vast majority of PSA’s often use images and scenarios centered on the outcome of pregnancy and fail to address the act that lead to that pregnancy. This commercial in particular attempts to scare the viewer into what their life may be like if they father a child but completely avoids addressing the activity of unprotected sex that lead to the fathering of a child. Furthermore, as discussed above, the images that are used are not realistic. Instead of giving adolescents actual models on how to change their behavior—there is a leap to the possible outcomes of that behavior.

Negotiating the use of a condom for example is not something that is commonly discussed with adolescents [12]. Instead of modeling the activity of a couple deciding to use a condom during sex and exactly how to use a condom correctly, that is all left to the viewer to figure out on their own.

The character in this PSA is a young male waking up in the morning and going through his routine. While it is important to include males in the conversation of unplanned pregnancy, it does not include a model of a couple that would be together making the decision to have protected sex. This sentiment is related to one of the five principles of the psychology of persuasion—communication theory [13, 14].

This principle is important in public health because who delivers the desired message is actually important. Instead of adolescents hearing a message about safe sex from an adult, it is ideal to hear that message from another adolescent. While this PSA does feature an adolescent, there really is not a way to connect with this character through the brief PSA in a way that makes the audience feel as if there is any commonality between them and the character pictured. Also, one could argue that this PSA would have very little connection to a female adolescent viewing it because throughout the entire PSA, there is no female pictured.

Utilization of Negative Labeling

This PSA utilizes negative labeling as a central tenant to the message it is conveying. It is not uncommon for PSA’s around sexual health, especially those geared towards adolescents, to use this sentiment. Again, however, the labeling is focused on the outcome of unprotected sex (pregnancy) and not the actual act of unprotected sex itself being the focus of the message.

Overall, there is a negative label that is associated with teen pregnancy in the United States [15]. Klein et al. describe this phenomenon as being related to the notion that pregnant adolescents are seen as not fulfilling their role as adolescents, failing to remain in school in some instances, failure to establish a stable family and failure to establish a vocation prior to starting a family and the parents often do not marry.

In this PSA, the negative label that is portrayed focuses on the outcome of a pregnancy leading to a “complicated life” when you have the responsibility of taking care of a child as a teenager is the message. This negative labeling of being an adolescent parent is focused solely on the change to one’s morning routine and not to some of the bigger-picture aspects of becoming a parent at a young age.

Again the labeling is around the outcome of pregnancy and there is no labeling—either positive or negative-around sexuality or the actual act of using appropriate contraception. It is almost like there is no connection to the activity that leads to the pregnancy because it is mostly ignored by this public health campaign.

There has been a lot of research around the association of labeling in adolescents in reference to delinquency [16], drug abuse [17] and mental health [18]. Overall, this research finds that poorer outcomes (i.e. repeat interactions with the justice system, failed abstinence from drug use, etc) were associated with instances when adolescents were labeled. While there hasn’t been published research around the concept of negative labeling and its association to teen sexuality and subsequent pregnancy per se, one could infer that previous research around other risk-taking behaviors has shown the use of negative labeling of adolescents is not beneficial.

Finally, the concept of ambivalence is not really addressed in this PSA and almost worsened by the negative labeling that is utilized. It has been noted in the literature that the lack of contraceptive use by adolescents can be somewhat attributed to their ambivalence to preventing pregnancy [19]. This lack of motivation is not helped by having a commercial make the claim that your life will be “complicated.” For some adolescents, the unrealistic complication depicted in this commercial of your hand being non-functional as you try and brush your teeth in the morning is not going to be powerful enough to overcome this sentiment of ambivalence.

Alternative Approach

Despite these critiques of current public health approaches, there are alternative approaches to the public health problem of teenage pregnancy in the United States. Once such program has been developed in San Antonio, TX and is entitled “ME NOW…baby later”[20]. This program is actually in alliance with the San Antonio Metropolitan Health District and their program entitled “Project W•O•R•T•H” and a non-profit organization called “The Healthy Futures Alliance: a community coalition to prevent teen and unplanned pregnancy.” Thus there is a lot of input from a variety of different sources and also legitimacy to the messages because of the alliances that have been created around this topic.

San Antonio has a high rate of teen pregnancy and birth compared to the nation as a whole. For example, according to 2007 data, the teen birth rate in Bexar County (where San Antonio is located) was 38.4 births/1000 females age 15-17 years old [21]. This birth rate is 73% higher than the nation as a whole. Therefore, there is a definitive need to address this problem within San Antonio and various organizations have come together to begin to effect change.

Utilization of Advertising Theory

Rather than approach the issue of teen pregnancy from the perspective of traditional health models that mainly focus on the individual and the assumption of rational behavior, advertising theory can be utilized [22]. When used within public health, advertising theory conveys a message that has mass appeal and consists of three tenants: a promise, support and core values

The first tenant is the promise and is considered the centerpiece of the advertisement. In the “ME NOW…baby later campaign” the video on the main page features a young female adolescent asking a group of diverse adolescents what “Me Now” means to them. Their answers range from finishing high school to attending medical school and all focus around the idea that concentrating on your time as an adolescent is important. Therefore, the promise of this campaign is that you can dream to accomplish anything as long as you focus on yourself now and wait to be a parent later. This promise is much different than the PSA from the National Campaign to End Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy which promised that your hand would turn into a baby doll if you got pregnant.

The second tenant of advertising theory is support which is provided through images and stories instead of solely based on statistics. For example, the opening video has various teenagers explaining their future goals and plans centered on the concept of delaying parenting. This is important because these teenagers are people you can believe and connect with-and their future aspirations are those that anyone in high school may have. The adolescents interviewed make the message of delaying parenting believable. It should also be noted that the background of this commercial appears to be a school classroom, which is another reminder to the goals given by the teenagers of completing high school and continuing on for further education.

Although not technically part of the concept of support within Advertising Theory, the website for this campaign is also very helpful in providing support for these two concepts. There is a section entitled “Baby Later” that actually gives you a brief overview of the options for contraception in order to not get pregnant. Additional links to medical clinics within San Antonio that specifically offer services to adolescents without parental notification, without insurance and without an appointment are listed. These characteristics for medical care are important to provide for adolescents who may desire to get contraception but are unable to do so for a variety of reasons. So, while this is not shown in the video through images or stories, there is further support on the website on how to make the promise happen.

The third tenant of advertising theory is the utilization of core values. The slogan for this campaign itself encompasses various core values such as youth, rebelliousness, independence, success, family and parenting. The video on the website further illustrates these core values by having the adolescents talk about what the slogan of the campaign means to them. By focusing on the idea of “Me Now” there is a theme of self-centeredness and entitlement that also works into the sense of rebellion that exists within adolescence.

Utilization of Modeling

The utilization of adolescents talking about delaying pregnancy is also important from a modeling perspective. Therefore, instead of telling adolescents what to do, we should show them what to do. For this campaign, the focus is on delaying pregnancy and the message is delivered by other teenagers that have made the decision to delay pregnancy and why that decision is important to them.

Another aspect of this campaign that is not only pertinent to San Antonio is the importance of diversity within modeling. As you can see from the video, there are a group of diverse adolescents answering the question of what “Me Now” means to them. Both genders are represented and there is more than one racial and ethnic background depicted through the adolescents that were chosen to participate. Additionally, there are photographs of adolescents on the website that represent a diverse group of adolescents.

A way to incorporate modeling into this campaign that is not currently a part of the “Me Now…baby later” campaign would be to also include images and stories of adolescents choosing various methods of birth control and how that decision was made. It would be even more interesting to include a video that portrayed a realistic conversation between two sexually active teenagers discussing their options for contraception.

Given the relative uncomfortable nature in the United States around sexuality, it would likely be difficult to include a very realistic conversation, for example one that occurs during foreplay. However, in media right now, there is a lot of depiction of sex and very little if any portion of those images involve a discussion or even utilization of contraception options [23]. Therefore, as public health officials we must use the same avenues that teenagers are exposed to and push the envelope to include safe-sex decisions and the use of contraception. The more modeling that can be depicted of sexually active adolescents actually making decisions around this concept, the more helpful that is to utilizing the concept of modeling.

Utilization of Positive Labeling

As mentioned earlier, the utilization of negative labeling can have impacts on adolescent behavior when it comes to other risk-taking behaviors. While most campaigns around teen pregnancy and safe sex rely on negative labeling and shame the outcome of pregnancy, the “Me Now…baby later” campaign does the opposite.

The catch phrase of this campaign “Me Now” sounds much more empowering and something that an adolescent would want to belong to instead of the last line of the previously discussed campaign—“Don’t Complicate Life.” This campaign from San Antonio is similar to the anti-smoking campaign targeted towards youth in Massachusetts entitled “The Eighty-Four” [24].

Using the same principals of positive labeling, the Eight-Four campaign approaches teen smoking by enticing them to be a part of the 84% of teenagers that don’t smoke. This is a campaign that makes adolescents feel empowered to be a part of it-the majority in fact. In addition, it is powerful to stand up as a group and say that you are not going to participate in a behavior like smoking. Often in adolescence there is a sense that everyone is smoking or everyone is having sex, and if you can dispel that myth and make adolescents feel like they are a part of something for not doing that behavior, it can be very effective.

The “Me Now…baby later” campaign also addresses the issue of adolescent ambivalence towards pregnancy prevention and thus subsequent contraception use. By giving a message of “Me Now” and having teenagers be a part of a larger movement-there is the opportunity to be a part of something and not feel alone in their decisions to focus on their achievements now and delay parenting.

Finally, and just as important, the “Me Now…baby later” campaign slogan incorporates the concept that these young adults will all have the opportunity and potential to be wonderful parents at some point of their life. By concentrating on themselves now, it will enable them to have the tools to be a parent later is a positive message and label applied to the targeted audience. It is also helpful in terms of making a connection between current actions and future consequences in a positive way rather than the negative approach that so often other campaigns around teen pregnancy utilize.

Conclusion

Teen pregnancy is a huge problem for the United States, as is evidenced by our high rates of teen pregnancy compared to similarly developed countries. However, by using the health belief model framework and negative labeling and not using modeling in these campaigns, we are not going to succeed. Instead, a new approach must be emphasized that takes into account the irrationality that often lies around the decision to have unprotected sex. Such alternatives include advertising theory, positive labeling and modeling. With a fresh approach to this public health issue, there is potential to make a genuine impact on this issue and effect change for society as a whole.

References

1. Guttmacher, I. Facts on American Teens' Sexual and Reproductive Health. 2010 [cited 2010 December 1]; Available from: http://www.guttmacher.org/pubs/FB-ATSRH.html

2. Kmietowicz, Z., US and UK are top in teenage pregnancy rates. BMJ, 2002. 324(7350): p. 1354.

3. Paranjothy, S., et al., Teenage pregnancy: who suffers? Arch Dis Child, 2009. 94(3): p. 239-45.

4. Wiemann, C.M., et al., Pregnant adolescents: experiences and behaviors associated with physical assault by an intimate partner. Matern Child Health J, 2000. 4(2): p. 93-101.

5. Klein, J.D., Adolescent pregnancy: current trends and issues. Pediatrics, 2005. 116(1): p. 281-6.

6. Facts on American Teen's Sources of Information About Sex. In Brief: Fact Sheet 2011 April 26, 2011]; Available from: http://www.guttmacher.org/pubs/FB-Teen-Sex-Ed.html.

7. Jones, R.K., et al., Adolescents' reports of parental knowledge of adolescents' use of sexual health services and their reactions to mandated parental notification for prescription contraception. JAMA, 2005. 293(3): p. 340-8.

8. Chandra, A., et al., Does watching sex on television predict teen pregnancy? Findings from a national longitudinal survey of youth. Pediatrics, 2008. 122(5): p. 1047-54.

9. Sex Has Consequences Public Service Announcements. [cited 2011 April 26th]; Available from: <http://www.wvdhhr.org/appi/psa/pages/videos/babyhand_30.html>

10. Cameron, K.A., A practitioner's guide to persuasion: an overview of 15 selected persuasion theories, models and frameworks. Patient Educ Couns, 2009. 74(3): p. 309-17.

11. Kaye K., S.K., Sloup C, The Fog Zone: How Misperceptions, Magical Thinking, and Ambivaelcne Put Young Adults at Risk for Unplanned Pregnancy. 2009, The National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy: Washington DC.

12. Gebhardt, W.A., L. Kuyper, and G. Greunsven, Need for intimacy in relationships and motives for sex as determinants of adolescent condom use. Journal of Adolescent Health, 2003. 33(3): p. 154-164.

13. Cialdini, R., Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion. 2007, New York: Harper Collins Publishers.

14. DeFleur ML, B.-R.S., Theories of Mass Communication. 5th ed. 1989, White Plains, NY: Longman Inc.

15. KLEIN, L., Antecedents of Teenage Pregnancy. Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology, 1978. 21(4): p. 1151-1159.

16. Matsueda, R.L., Reflected Appraisals, Parental Labeling, and Delinquency: Specifying a Symbolic Interactionist Theory. The American Journal of Sociology, 1992. 97(6): p. 1577-1611.

17. Downs, W.R., J.F. Robertson, and L.R. Harrison, Control theory, labeling theory, and the delivery of services for drug abuse to adolescents. Adolescence, 1997. 32(125): p. 1-24.

18. Weinstein, R.M., Labeling Theory and the Attitudes of Mental Patients: A Review. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 1983. 24(1): p. 70-84.

19. Brückner, H., A. Martin, and P.S. Bearman, Ambivalence and Pregnancy:Adolescents'Attitudes, Contraceptive Use and Pregnancy. Perspectives on Sexual and Reproductive Health, 2004. 36(6): p. 248-257.

20. ME NOW...baby later. [cited 2011 April 26th]; Available from: http://www.menowbabylater.com/.

21. National Center for Health Statistics, N.V.S. Reports, Editor. 2007.

22. Maibach, E., Designing Health Messages: Approaches from Communication Theory and Public Health Practice. 1995, Thousand Oaks California: Sage Publications.

23. Wright, P., Sexual Socialization Messages in Mainstream Entertainment Mass Media: A Review and Synthesis. Sexuality & Culture, 2009. 13(4): p. 181-200.

24. The Eighty-Four. [cited 2011 May 5]; Available from: http://www.the84.org/.

Labels: , , ,